Having the Courage to Lead and Be Disliked
Don’t have time to read? Try listening instead.
Sometimes leadership boils down to one question: Will you make the right decision or the popular one?
Some leaders choose popularity. They avoid difficult conversations, delay necessary restructuring, and protect underperforming executives because they're friends. Their organizations pay the price.
The best leaders choose differently.
Consider Satya Nadella at Microsoft. When he took over in 2014, Microsoft was a dying empire clinging to Windows and Office. Nadella dismantled sacred cows. He killed Windows Phone. He embraced open-source software—heresy in the old Microsoft. He transformed the company's culture to prioritize collaboration and innovation.
Internal leaders resisted. Some left. The old guard believed he was destroying Microsoft's legacy. Nadella didn't care about their approval. He cared about survival. Microsoft's market cap tripled. He was right. They were wrong.
Or take Reed Hastings at Netflix. In 2011, he announced that Netflix would split its DVD and streaming businesses. The decision was an instant disaster. Wall Street revolted. Customers canceled in droves; 800,000 gone. The stock price collapsed 77%. Analysts called him delusional. The press mocked him relentlessly.
Hastings knew the truth: the DVD was dead. Streaming was the future. He could either protect a dying business model and his reputation or kill the DVD business and build the future. He chose the future. He was willing to torch everything: stock price, customer goodwill, and his own credibility rather than delay the inevitable.
Today, Netflix has 260 million subscribers and fundamentally changed how the world consumes entertainment. Hastings was right. The critics were wrong. But he had to be willing to be disliked to get there.
Or look at Congress. Both parties have spent decades kicking the can down the road on Social Security, Medicare, and the debt ceiling. Everyone knows the numbers don't add up. The Congressional Budget Office publishes the projections, and actuaries show the math. Everyone knows the fixes will be painful, including later retirement ages, means testing, and benefit adjustments.
But painful fixes cost votes. So, Congress avoids them. They choose short-term approval over long-term solvency. They're mortgaging your children's future because they lack the courage for an uncomfortable conversation today. That's not leadership. That's cowardice with a government salary (not to mention insider trading).
The Cost of Cowardice
Leadership cowardice destroys organizations from the inside out. The damage follows a predictable pattern.
First, your best people leave. High performers don't stick around to watch mediocrity go unchallenged. They find organizations with leaders who have spines.
Second, innovation dies. When people learn the real rule is "don't rock the boat," they stop taking risks. They stop challenging assumptions. They stop bringing you bad news. You end up surrounded by yes-men who tell you what you want to hear.
Third, your reputation plummets. Customers, investors, and employees can all smell weak leadership. They lose confidence, then they leave.
Boeing's 737 MAX is the textbook case. Engineers raised safety concerns. Leadership buried them. Production timelines mattered more. Shareholder expectations mattered more. Maintaining "collaborative relationships" with the board mattered more.
The result: 346 people dead, nearly $20 billion in losses, and a company that almost destroyed itself. That's one dramatic example of what happens when leaders choose comfort over courage.
What Real Leadership Requires
True leadership isn't complicated. It requires four things:
Purpose over popularity: You make decisions based on what's right for the mission, not what protects your image.
Long-term thinking: Jamie Dimon has spent years warning about America's fiscal irresponsibility and making unpopular calls about bank regulation. He gets criticized constantly. He doesn't care. He prioritizes financial stability over quarterly popularity scores.
Accountability without exceptions: When Arvind Krishna took over IBM in 2020, he split the company and spun off the legacy infrastructure business. Longtime IBMers revolted, but Krishna didn't back down. Transformation requires bold moves, not consensus-building exercises.
Honesty about hard choices: Don't pretend tough decisions are easy. Acknowledge the difficulty. Explain why they're necessary. Move forward. That builds trust, even when people disagree.
The Choice
Every leader will likely face the same choice: effective or liked?
As a leader, you will face situations that demand courage. The question is whether you'll have the resolve to act when that moment arrives.
The cost of courage is temporary discomfort. The cost of cowardice is permanent regret.
Want to fast-track your executive development? Let's work together to identify exactly where you are now and create a personalized roadmap for where you want to go. Because generic advice gets generic results—but targeted coaching? That's where transformation happens. Set up an appointment.
